Volume 16 Number 3 (May. 2021)
Home > Archive > 2021 > Volume 16 Number 3 (May. 2021) >
JSW 2021 Vol.16(3): 95-106 ISSN: 1796-217X
doi: 10.17706/jsw.16.3.95-106

Permissioned vs. Permissionless Blockchain: How and Why There Is Only One Right Choice

Siamak Solat1, 2*, Philippe Calvez1, Farid Naït-Abdesselam2, 3
1ENGIE, Laboratory for Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence (CSAI), Paris, France
2University of Paris, France.
3University of Missouri Kansas City, USA.

Abstract—The blockchain structure can be utilized in an efficient way to verify and ensure the integrity of the data and prevent historical transactions from tampering, such that if one block is altered, then the rest of next blocks are no longer valid. However, it is possible to re-calculate all the next blocks in a closed and permissioned network, such that all altered blocks will become valid again. In other words, only chaining blocks to each other, based on the hash of the previous one, cannot ensure the integrity and the security of the data and protect transactions against tampering. In this paper, we motivate why permissionless blockchain in an open network should be considered as the only acceptable type of blockchain and show that permissioned blockchain and closed network makes chaining transactions (i.e. blockchain) as an unhelpful structure. Of course, this never means that we ignore the existing problems in permissionless blockchains (such as, scalability of the network and transaction throughput), but also, we argue that permissioned blockchain cannot be an acceptable solution for those problems, where chaining transactions will no longer be meaningful. In other words, in a closed network, we no longer need to chain transactions. Although, this is a central issue and has been addressed in recent years, we are trying to bring new elements and an enriched point of view.

Index Terms—Blockchain, tamper-evidence, tamper-resistance, data-integrity, proof-of-work.


Cite: Siamak Solat, Philippe Calvez, Farid Naït-Abdesselam, "Permissioned vs. Permissionless Blockchain: How and Why There Is Only One Right Choice," Journal of Software vol. 16, no. 3, pp. 95-106, 2021.

Copyright © 2021 by the authors. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited (CC BY 4.0)

General Information

ISSN: 1796-217X (Online)
Frequency:  Bimonthly (Since 2020)
Editor-in-Chief: Prof. Antanas Verikas
Executive Editor: Ms. Yoyo Y. Zhou
Abstracting/ Indexing: DBLP, EBSCO, Google Scholar, ProQuest, INSPEC(IET), ULRICH's Periodicals Directory, WorldCat, etc
E-mail: jsw@iap.org
  • Apr 26, 2021 News!

    Vol 14, No 4- Vol 14, No 12 has been indexed by IET-(Inspec)     [Click]

  • Jun 22, 2020 News!

    Papers published in JSW Vol 14, No 1- Vol 15 No 4 have been indexed by DBLP     [Click]

  • Sep 13, 2021 News!

    The papers published in Vol 16, No 6 have all received dois from Crossref    [Click]

  • Jan 28, 2021 News!

    [CFP] 2021 the annual meeting of JSW Editorial Board, ICCSM 2021, will be held in Rome, Italy, July 21-23, 2021   [Click]

  • Sep 13, 2021 News!

    Vol 16, No 6 has been published with online version     [Click]